Petoskey, a Northern Michigan city, is a four-season destination and among the five waterfront resort communities forming the Petoskey Area. It’s a haven for the outdoorsy types who enjoy unlimited outdoor activities at any season. In Petoskey State Park, you can go camping by the lake, discover hiking trails, or go hunting for Petoskey stones along the shores. Its “Million Dollar Sunsets” and lovely vistas of Little Traverse Bay and Lake Michigan are must-see. It also has a Gaslight District, a shopping mecca for affluent visitors.
Some luxury resort hotels near train depots built in 1874 are a testimony to Petoskey’s rapid growth. To fully experience the city, check out the best historic hotels in Petoskey, Michigan, below.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) properties with historic significance, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on October 30, 2025.
1. Stafford's Perry Hotel (from USD 265)
This famous heritage hotel is at the intersection of Bay and Lewis Streets. It was first owned by dentist Dr. Norman Perry in 1899 and has undergone several changes since then. It’s listed as a Historic Site in the National Register and the State of Michigan. It’s also the only hotel still operating from the 1900s.
The main lobby has been restored to its former elegance to wow guests walking in. Meanwhile, its luxurious guest rooms combine antique furnishings and modern conveniences. Select rooms even have a balcony with jaw-dropping bay views.
There’s an on-site fine-dining restaurant and a veranda for al fresco dining with panoramic bay vistas. Later, enjoy spirited drinks at the on-site bar.
Perry Hotel
Address: 100 Lewis Street
3.21 km (2.0 mi) from Odawa Casino
Nearby historic hotels
2. Stafford's Bay View Inn (from USD 117)
Stafford’s Bay View Inn was built in 1886 by John Wesly Howard and was called Woodland Avenue House. The property underwent some renovations and name changes until 1935 when it was named Bay View Inn.
The Smith family became its innkeepers when it was sold in 1961. They restored and maintained the grandeur of this Victorian-style inn for over 60 years. Thanks to their efforts, it is now the oldest summer hotel in the northern area of Michigan’s Grand Rapids.
Here, you’ll find spacious guest rooms and suites oozing with unique interiors and old-world charm. Some rooms offer a gorgeous view of Little Traverse Bay. To round off your experience, enjoy Sunday brunch at its on-site restaurant.
Stafford's Bay View Inn
Address: 2011 Woodland Ave
5.39 km (3.4 mi) from Odawa Casino
3. The Earl (from USD 185)
This historic boutique hotel in the Charlevoix area was once Weathervane Lodge owned by architect Earl Young in 1959. It’s famous for the Beaver stone by the entrance, its turrets, classic stone fireplaces, and its rooftop bar. The current owners renovated it in 2019, keeping the original structure and adding some modern features.
Its current name is etched on the Beaver stone and modern additions were added to the lobby’s original interior design. Further in, the guestrooms and suites combine contemporary interiors and vintage furnishings. Luckily, The Earl also has a host of modern amenities to keep guests hooked. There are indoor and outdoor pools and spa tubs for luxuriating and an on-site gym for exercising. Plus, you can have cocktails or host corporate events at the rooftop bar.
The Earl
Address: 120 Michigan Ave
22.21 km (13.8 mi) from Odawa Casino
Stay in hotels rich with history in Petoskey
When visiting Petoskey and its nearby areas, be sure to include historic hotels in your itinerary for a unique stay. Their colorful past will make your stay an exciting experience. Book from the list above to ensure the best experience for you and your loved ones.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data